Photography Blog from

Big News: Benedict Cumberbatch & Justin Bieber

Big News

Big News

Big News in the rumour mill of mass media culture is Justin Bieber’s unconfirmed role in the Star Trek Into Darkness movie. While everyone has been concentrating on Benedict Cumberbatch’s character in the movie, no one has yet said anything about this piece of marketing hype. All Cumberbatch has said is ” that he is not Khan”.

Justin Bieber was heard to say ” baby, baby”, possibly referring to his supposed role as genetically modified youth, which would tie in to the Khan hypothesis and the movie trailer Star Trek Into Darkness references the Cumberbatch character talking to concerned parents about their child.

Advanced Vaudeville - Bieber Shakes Harper

Advanced Vaudeville – Bieber Shakes Harper

It is difficult to know what to make of this Justin Bieber Star Trek connection. The Grey Cup half-time show demonstrated that celebrity poularity does not guarantee effective marketing or broadening of target audience. ( See: Grey Cup Boos , The Risk of Celebrity Worship & Get Justin Bieber in Your Classroom to Teach Media Literacy ) Time will tell if this marketing ploy will have a positive or negative effect, perhaps the intent is to generate public interest and keep the names of the celebrities and the movie in the headlines.

The Earl Albert Grey donated the Grey Cup in 1909.

The passage of time and Mass Media, both in generated content and format, is part of the controversies surrounding both the Star Trek franchise and Bieber-mania. In both cases, we have different age demographics with varied perceptions of the content and the delivery of that content. Depending on one’s age and gender, Justin Bieber’s fame/celebrity status seems justified or out of proportion. Bieber’s success came through very effective use of social media to reach the intended target audience. Social media solidified and maintains this success, but at a price. The content can not change/ evolve in style, form or information. Success hardens, like amber, to trap the celebrity.

Furthermore, the community that embraces this content does not welcome change or criticism. Those who observe the content and the community from the outside will make comparisons to other teen & tween idols of the past. They will be less impressed by the Bieber’s career ( the message is not directed at them & it will seem less unique or special) and they will find the fan fervour an antagonizing barrier.

The Bachelor and the Bobby Soxer

We see a similar problem with the Star Trek franchise. The franchise grew out of a beloved television series. Attempts to re-imagine and convey the message of the show in the form of a feature length movie has had mixed results. Change the medium, change the message. Not all the films have been equally successful. The most recent attempt uses the trope of time travel triggering an alternate sequence of events to reboot the series. The original characters are re-imagined with new actors. The reality of Star Trek is constructed using present day cinema technology. Inevitably, various demographic groups will either be accepting or rejecting this version.

This brings us to the concept of what I call Necro-media. Necro-media refers to past forms of mass media and media content. Necro-media is often rediscovered by a new generation. This generation may embrace it in its original form, (lovers of Old Time Radio, silent films, or original pulp/fictional detectives) or they re-purpose the medium, (those who take up Alternative Photographic processes or attempt to emulate them using digital darkroom methods).

Yesterday's Print

Yesterday’s Print

The accompanying visuals fit into this latter example. The first image, Big News, suggests an aged photograph of times past. The subject are bundled newspapers & flyers, a print medium that some say is reaching the end of its days. The second image, Yesterday’s Print,makes use of an aged newspaper texture in combination of two book covers, Peter the Great by Nia Brown Baker (1943) & Dave Dawson at Singapore by R. Sidney Bowen (1942). Both works and writers were popular at their time ,writing for a early teen audience, combining accurate information with fanciful youthful adventure and a set values, beliefs and ideologies that today make them forms of Necro-media.

How to Enter Vaudeville

In Advanced Vaudeville – Bieber Shakes Harper the lost theatrical entertainment of vaudeville, child labour of the early 1900’s, Cab Calloway’s iconic face, contrast Bieber and Prime Minister Harper shaking hands when the youth was presented with a Queen Elizabeth II Diamond Jubilee Medal, designed “to honour significant contributions and achievements by Canadians.” Unfortunately his backwards cap and overalls were seen by some as disrespectful to the honour. Others thought that he was simply not deserving of the honour. What was the media message being sent out by the Prime Minister of Canada? What would Cab Calloway, famous for his signature style of dress think of the white teenager’s attempt at clean urban grundge ? For that matter, what of the children of 1910 in their working clothes , how might they respond to this ? Perhaps Vaudeville has not died. Like other Necro-media it has just resurfaced in a new form.

In a way, both the Star Trek brand and Bieber brand, are Necro-media. The first is much loved television series that been reborn in the 21st century in the evolving medium of cinema. Justin Bieber is part of a long line of popular singers, going back to Rudy Vallée, whose popularity was first spread by the dominant forms of Mass Media at the time, records (1928) and radio and movies (1929).


“Vallée also became what was perhaps the first complete example of the 20th century mass mediapop star. Flappers mobbed him wherever he went. His live appearances were usually sold out, and even if his singing could hardly be heard in those venues not yet equipped with the new electronic microphones, his screaming female fans went home happy if they had caught sight of his lips through the opening of the trademark megaphone he sang through. A brief caricature of him in the Fleischer Brothers‘ color Betty Boop theatrical short cartoon from 1934 Poor Cinderella depicts him singing through a megaphone .”

Rudy Vallee caricature

Necro-media and an application of Media analysis helps us put the Bieber Star Trek rumour in context. I hope to further explore the topic of Necro-media, both through visual creations and analysis of mass media events, real & imagined. Enjoy the day.


12 responses

  1. Very interesting and enjoyable, Joseph.

    December 17, 2012 at 5:09 am

    • elmediat

      Thanks Ashley. My Media Literacy blog has been inactive int terms of new posts. The ideas keep bleeding over into this blog. 🙂

      December 17, 2012 at 9:15 am

  2. Michelle Gillies

    Joseph, this is fascinating stuff. Necro – media certainly bares more exploration and I will eagerly wait for more from you but I think I may have a look around myself as well.

    December 17, 2012 at 8:43 am

    • elmediat

      Thanks Michelle. The idea was stirred up by how on the one hand people are exploring the hands on alternative processes in photography, analog photography and steampunk design and fashion, while at the same time there are all sorts of apps and plug-ins being popularized so that we can re-create the aesthetic of a by-gone age using the digital medium. Then there are those who photograph old cameras and other forms of older media, turning them into the subject of new media. This started the chain of ideas flowing.
      See Robert’s two posts for examples of what I mean:

      Robert really explores this area in many different forms and they are all wonderful pieces of art.

      December 17, 2012 at 9:26 am

      • Michelle Gillies

        Agreed. I like his work and do follow him.

        December 17, 2012 at 9:34 am

  3. If Justin Bieber is singing in space… can you still hear him?!

    December 17, 2012 at 2:41 pm

    • elmediat

      Oh that was priceless ! 😀

      There are those who would be willing to send him up there and use the Canadarm (SRMS) to find out. I think some of those people were at the Grey Cup this year.

      December 17, 2012 at 3:07 pm

  4. Pingback: time gentlemen, please | Implied Spaces

  5. Pingback: The Radio Star Video Killed with a Tablet – The Happy Wall | Implied Spaces

  6. Pingback: “The Old New World” – an example of Necro- Media | Dark Pines Media

  7. Pingback: Implied Space – Deconstructed Wave | Implied Spaces

  8. Pingback: time gentlemen, please – Implied Spaces

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s